Montauk Monster: Ten Years Later

On July 23, 2008, the news first circulated of a strange carcass found July 12, 2008, on a New York-area island. Then I, cryptozoologist Loren Coleman, coined the body the “Montauk Monster,” on July 29, 2008.

According to Wikipedia:

Cryptozoologist Loren Coleman at Cryptomundo first coined the name the “Montauk Monster” on July 29, 2008. The nickname was disseminated globally on the Internet in the following days. Photographs were widely circulated via email and weblogs, and the national media picked up on it raising speculation about the creature. The potential urban legend stature of the Montauk Monster was noted by Snopes.

The monster has been discussed on Conspiracy Theory with Jesse Ventura. On August 4, 2011 the Montauk Monster was featured on the second episode of the third season of Ancient Aliens, titled “Aliens and Monsters”. [Loren Coleman was featured in the episode, on site at the International Cryptozoology Museum.]

During the time of the tenth anniversary of this event, two journalists reflected on the overall media mania of the incident. I have extracted quotes from their treatments regarding my part in what occurred.


“10 Years Later The Montauk Monster Is Still a Weird, Gross, Dark Mystery”

The Observer

By Ellen Killoran • 07/28/18

Loren Coleman, a veteran cryptozoologist based in Portland, Maine, knew about the Montauk Monster before most of us did — in fact, he named it.

Coleman told the Observer that he started getting messages from friends and colleagues about the curious carcass after it made the local news on July 23, 2008, but before Gawker picked it up. And he was skeptical, but not for the reason that some of us might be. After all, cryptozoology is a “pseudoscience” that takes folklore like Bigfoot and chupacabras very seriously—and Coleman is at the top of his field. A self-described fan of alliteration, he coined the term “Dover Demon” back in 1977, after a Massachusetts schoolboy swore on a stack of bibles that he saw a devilish creature with glowing eyes and “tendril-like fingers” sitting on a stone wall in the distant Boston suburb. In his field, Coleman has plenty of admirers.

“July 12 is my birthday, and a lot of people all around the world celebrate my birthday and send me all kinds of greetings,” Coleman said. “So I wondered if they were trying to hoax me. I was very suspicious of it in the beginning.”

Coleman said he tried to make arrangements to see the monster for himself. “It wasn’t impossible for me to get to New York,” he said. “I was open to taking a look, but nobody would produce it.”

He tried to make contact with the three women who took the photo, but just like the carcass, “they seemed to disappear. These people put up a brick wall around themselves.”

*** 01_montaukmonstercnn_lgl


The cryptozoologist would agree that the story has credibility. Loren Coleman is certain that the Montauk Monster was a decomposing raccoon.

“All you had to do was look at it and know a little bit about zoology, which I do, and you would see that it was barely second-day disintegration and decaying of a [raccoon’s] body,” Coleman said.

He went on to explain in great detail a process he called “skin flipping” [actually, "skin slipping" ~ LC] that can happen to a body being tossed around in the surf, and purportedly accounts for why the animal’s facial structure appeared distorted —as though it had a beak. In short, the normal decomposition process combined with the movement through rough water can cause “slippage” between the surface skin and the underlying fat.

“It’s disgusting,” Coleman said.

While the cryptozoologist dismissed any of the more fantastical explanations for the Montauk Monster, he believes the story started a trend of cryptid sightings. “Very quickly after that, quote unquote Montauk Monsters started showing up around the world,” Coleman said.

Putting himself at the center of the story paid off: Coleman said that the marketers of Venom Energy drink asked him to provide a quote they used in a campaign to promote a Montauk Monster-themed beverage.

“I turned around and they had paid me $1,000,” Coleman said. “I felt I was cheating them or something.”


The Montauk Monster Eli Neugeboren for Observer




David Wright Photos.



“The Montauk Monster Legend Endures 10 Years After It Broke the Internet: Jenna Hewitt snapped the infamous photo exactly a decade ago, on July 12, 2008″ by Oliver Peterson Dan’s Papers: This is the Hamptons! July 12, 2018

Most sensible people probably understood that the Montauk Monster—a term coined by leading cryptozoologist and Bigfoot researcher Loren Coleman—had a fairly pedestrian explanation, but boy, was it fun to speculate!

Bloggers jumped on the Plum Island idea. People guessed it might be a turtle without its shell, or some equally unlikely freak of nature. TV naturalist Jeff Corwin weighed in. Jesse Ventura investigated the case on his Conspiracy Theory show. Coleman revisited it in a 2009 episode of History’s Monster Quest. Nearly every serious examination concluded it was indeed a decayed raccoon carcass.


Montauk Monster, illustrated by Eloy Manzanero for Dan’s Paper.


A gallery of photos and side treks with the Montauk Monster.

The classic, widely published picture:


Other views of the body soon materialized.


Montauk Banner



“The Montauk Monster” article by Loren Coleman appeared in the August/September 2008 issue of TAPS Paramagazine.

Hunter Shea - Montauk Monster cover

Hunter Shea’s book.



Was there a link between the Montauk Monster and Stranger Things? I looked at that question here.

The Montauk Monster also entered politics…







Montauk 2  copy


and as an early display at the International Cryptozoology Museum in 2009.






 Will the public and media even care to remember in 2028? Or in 3008?